For my next ice cream challenge I decided to go for gold and attempt a chocolate peanut butter flavor. This would be my favorite combination for ice cream, as well as NB’s so it was a win-win in my book. Again, I used Ben & Jerry’s chocolate as a base.
You will need:

4 ounces Unsweetened chocolate
1 cup Milk (doesn’t specify, I used 1%)
2 large Eggs
1 cup Sugar
1 cup Heavy or whipping cream
1 teaspoon Vanilla
1 pinch Salt
1/2 cup smooth peanut butter Don’t use the natural kind, as the oil won’t freeze correctly)
4 5th Avenue Bars, or whatever chocolate peanut butter candy you prefer
First I chopped the 5th Avenue Bars into 1/2 inch chunks and put them into a covered container, so I could freeze them, while I made the base.

For the chocolate base, start with a double broiler with hot water, but make sure it’s not boiling. I don’t have a formal double broiler so I used a heat-proof bowl over a sauce pan. Place the unsweetened chocolate into the double broiler.

Stir until fully melted and smooth, it will be thick.

Next gently whisk in the milk, until smooth.

Remove the chocolate mixture from heat, cover and place into the refrigerator for 1-3 hours, until cold, the time will depend on your fridge.
After it’s cooled down, start mixing the basic base. In a large bowl, beat the eggs, until their fluffy and light in color. (I used a bowl that had been in the freezer, which is why the sides look a little different, this wasn’t necessary)

Next, add the sugar, 1/4 cup at a time, blend after each addition. Once fully incorporated, mix one minute more. When you’re adding the sugar, the mix becomes slightly thicker.

Now whisk in the heavy cream and pinch of salt. Once it’s added and blended, take the chocolate base out of the fridge and add to the cream base.

Whisk until fully incorporated.

Remove 1 cup of the ice cream before placing into the mixer and add the 1/2 cup of peanut butter to it.
Put the remaining mixture, into your ice cream maker bowl. Let mix for 20 minutes, or how ever long your mixer takes to become a thick ice cream consistency.
Once it’s reached a thicker ice cream state, add the frozen 5th Avenue chunks and the chocolate peanut butter combination and let mix for 5 extra minutes. Unfortunately I don’t have a picture of this. Once you’ve let it mix, transfer mix to a freezer safe container and freeze for 6 hours (again, your freezer may take less or more time).
Now, it’s time for a tasty treat!

